Ugh. You keep at this. Look, what is better for me, VASTLY better, is a tool that goes the direction I want to go. Because I only need it for going home at the end of a shift.
Why do you need a trip home? Isn't it to make money? What would it matter that you can't get a $20 trip home if you make at least $20 more during your shift?
Maybe you're not in a UFF market, but if you are, you can just use that to get a trip home. That's what I do. I do take low paying trips... but ONLY to get somewhere I want to go.
When surge pricing is in effect, generally in the center of town, I ONLY drive with Lyft, as I can cherry pick short rides based on destination, which Lyft shows me (and Uber does not).
Yes at time of course Lyft pays better than Uber. But there are lots of times Uber's surge is double or even triple what Lyft's is and/or covers a much larger area. During those times, you'll want a tool that helps maximize your earnings on Uber. Even if it's an inferior tool to what Lyft gives you. Because it's not so bad that it can't make up for a surge difference of 2x - 3x.
Usually if it's surging... I mean "real" surge or "hard" surge, not "fake" surge, normal pings will be so constant that they are FREQUENT EVEN WITH YOUR DF SET TO A NEARBY LOCATION. That's all you need. A little bit of downtime is acceptable if it is offset by a higher profit margin and earnings on your next trip.
I do not believe that using Uber while fiddling around with a destination filter is going to do better than that for money.
Maybe in your market. But in Chicago there are plenty of times when you'd be dead wrong. Those are usually the best times to drive here.
And with no surge pricing in effect, I fail to see how screwing around with a destination filter is going to make more money than not.
If there's no surge in effect, WHY THE HELL ARE YOU DRIVING? No surge, no drive*
If you can't earn enough money during surge times then you'd be better off supplementing your income with something else. Even if it's a part time gig at a fast food restaurant.
If it never surges in your market then you're probably better off not driving for U/L at all, and just work a full time W2 of almost any kind. Otherwise, at BEST you're barely beating minimum wage after expenses FOR A DANGEROUS JOB WITH NO BENEFITS, NO FUTURE AND NO UPWARD MOBILITY, and at worst you're risking your life to borrow money against the equity in your vehicle.
If you're upside down on a loan on your vehicle and when there's no surge in your market and no promo to chase and you're driving for U/L, then god help you.
If you're constantly battling downtime between trips even when you aren't filtering them or fishing for a unicorn, GIVE IT UP man. Either go home or drive to the place where there is actually demand, because where you are it's BEYOND DEAD.
-------------------------------------------------------------
* regarding no surge no drive, it may make sense to chase promos like quests/challenges/guarantees when there is no surge, but then you also want short trips so DF comes back into play
* also, "hidden" surge is the only other reason to drive when it's not (visibly) surging, but I've not found that to be very predictable in Chicago except for a few instances when I know demand is extremely high yet Uber is mysteriously not surging, or is uncharacteristically lower than Lyft's.